Case Studies

Case Studies

With more than 100 years of combined litigation experience, the attorneys at Ice Legal have played a pivotal role in legal development. Our groundbreaking cases have been featured in news stories across the county and have set new legal precedents that continue to help clients and Florida residents.

Our case studies act as an example of what the professional litigation team at Ice Legal is capable of. We are proud of our substantial litigation experience and the innovative results we achieve are evidence of that.

Glarum v. LaSalle Bank National Association

Tom Ice, founder and principal legal strategist of the firm, represented homeowners Gary and Anita Glarum. The decision received significant news coverage at both the state and national level because servicing employees have routinely signed affidavits of indebtedness that mortgage servicers use to prove the amount of money owed.The groundbreaking decision had broad implications in foreclosures cases throughout the state.

The Impact of the Case

In the trial courts, the Glarum case is often mentioned by one or both sides at a foreclosure summary judgment hearing and is familiar to most attorneys in the foreclosure practice area.

Additional Reading


Machado

Israel Machado, Florida homeowner, came to Ice Legal with what looked like a typical foreclosure case. Ice Legal proved that the affidavit used by the bank to support its motion for summary judgment was signed by a robo-signer.

Additional Reading


Opera Place

Ice Legal represented realtors whose commissions for selling luxury condos had never been paid.  After the realtors wrested control of the property from the condo builder as payment for the commissions, a company purporting to be a mortgagee of the property sought foreclosure, which would have extinguished the realtors’ claims without them ever collecting the commissions.  Ice Legal proved a series of connections between the builder and the purported mortgagee that supported the argument that the foreclosure was a ruse for the builder to regain control of the property.  The case was settled at mediation. 

Additional Reading


Roman Pino v. The Bank of New York

Roman Pino v. The Bank of New Yorkwas the first case arising from the foreclosure crisis to reach the Florida Supreme Court.  In the trial court, Ice Legal brought evidence that the assignment had been backdated and asked the court to punish the bank with a dismissal. 

To avoid permanent dismissal, the bank chose to voluntarily dismiss the case so that it could be filed again later.  Ice Legal challenged whether the bank could escape punishment for falsifying evidence before the court.  As a result, the case was settled and the Florida Supreme Court called for a rule change to permit courts to punish litigants who intentionally mislead the court.

Additional Reading